This week Sports Illustrated’s Ian Thomsen interviewed NBA Commissioner David Stern, among the topics discussed; will a women ever play in the National Basketball Association?

This look scares me...
I asked if we might see a woman playing NBA basketball within a decade.
“I think we might,” said Stern. “I don’t want to get into all kinds of arguments with players and coaches about the likelihood. But I really think it’s a good possibility.”
The media, and more specifically men have a habit of trying to legitimize womens professional sports by drawing comparisons in talent. The prevailing thought seems to be that the most dominant female athlete in her sport should be able to compete in the mens league.
It’s no secret that the NFL, NBA, MLB are the cash cows of sport. People pay the most to go to these games in person, and the most people watch these spots on TV. The exact opposite can be said of the WNBA, Softball, and Field Hockey. It’s not that these sports are necessarily bad, or that the women playing them are unathletic; but compared to males their physical prowess and stature is dwarfed. And when the primary candidate to watch sports is a male 18-48, they don’t want to watch something they feel is inferior in comparison.

One of a select few WNBA players who can dunk.
But if a women can be competitive against men, well, that changes the dynamic, and adds an aura of credibility around the womens game. That’s the prevailing logic, but is it really all that sound? Lets take a look at how women fair competing against men, starting with Billie Jean King.
1973 – Billie Jean King wins the “Battle of the Sexes” against Bobby Riggs
2000-2004 – Katie Hnida becomes the first female to score a point in division 1 college football. Later accused player on University of Colorado of rape while she was on the team.
2000-Current – Michelle Wie becomes the first woman to play in a PGA tour event in 2004 at the age of 14. She missed the cut. She played 5 more times in the next 3 years; missing the cut in all of them. Just recently she won her first LPGA tournament.
2005-Current – Danica Patrick becomes the first woman to win an F1 race in 2008 with a win over in Japan. Her career F1 record is 82 starts, 1 win, 3 poles, 16 top 5 finishes.
The prevailing theme throughout those 4 examples is that these women became the ‘first to’ do something in their sports. So the question must be asked; is it the novelty/marketing, or the actual athletic prowess that is the reason gifted women are competing in these events?

She will be racing in NASCAR next year.
Sadly, it looks to be the former. Having one moment, or triumph is not sustainable. You may see a woman play in the NBA, and score a basket. Headlines would go crazy, but the odds of her becoming a legitimate threat off the bench, or start putting up 4 points a game in limited time is very very unlikely. So would that be a battle cry for all women of similar skill to migrate to the NBA? Not so much.
If the NBA knows whats best, it should not allow a woman to play in the league. They setup the WNBA for a reason; to give women with talent in basketball a professional league, not a jumping off point to get to the NBA. We should as a society be able to appreciate the talents of both men and women in sports without the need to intertwine the two.